You’ve been saving up all year for that summer trip to the Hamptons, and now you’re finally here, ready to dine at the best restaurants the area has to offer. With so many amazing options, how do you choose? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. We’ve scoured reviews, analyzed menus, and taste-tested everything from fresh-caught Montauk lobster rolls to Wagyu beef tartare with truffle aioli to bring you the definitive list of the best restaurants in the Hamptons. Whether you’re in the mood for an upscale meal with stunning waterfront views, a low-key farm-to-table brunch, or gourmet takeout to enjoy at the beach, this list has something for every craving and occasion. Get ready for an unforgettable summer of dining as we reveal the best of the best in the Hamptons.
Can’t-Miss Farm-to-Table Dining Experiences
The Hamptons are known for fresh seafood, so you can’t go wrong at any of these spots.
The Lobster Inn
This casual Clam Bar and seafood shack in Amagansett is the place to go for lobster rolls, fish tacos, and fish and chips. Open since the 1920s, they source sustainable and local seafood. Order at the counter and enjoy ocean breezes on their patio.
The Clam Bar at Napeague
A classic drive-in style seafood spot open since the 1950s. They’re known for whole belly clams, lobster rolls, and fish fry platters. Everything is super fresh and you can get it to go or dine al fresco at picnic tables with views of Napeague Bay.
Cove Hollow Tavern
An upscale yet unpretentious seafood restaurant in East Hampton with a menu highlighting local catches and produce. Start with their tuna tartare or lobster bisque before enjoying mains like pan-seared scallops, cioppino seafood stew or their famous “Clambake for Two”. They also offer a raw bar with oysters and clams.
Brunch Worth Waking Up For: Our Favorite Breakfast Joints
The Hamptons are a foodie’s paradise, especially if you’re looking for fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. Here are a few can’t-miss farm-to-table restaurants to try:
The Farmhouse
This charming eatery works with over 30 local farmers and food purveyors to create a menu that highlights the area’s bounty. Dishes like roasted heirloom carrots with pistachio dukkah and the grass-fed burger with house pickles are simple yet memorable. Their cocktail program also utilizes homemade syrups, tinctures and infusions.
– Location: Southampton, NY
– Price range: $$$
Nick & Toni’s
An institution since 1988, Nick & Toni’s Mediterranean-inspired menu is crafted from ingredients sourced within 100 miles. Their wood-burning oven produces amazing flatbreads, and entrees like local striped bass and suckling pig porchetta are sublime. They also have an extensive wine list featuring organic and biodynamic bottles.
– Location: East Hampton, NY
– Price range: $$$$
The 1770 House
For an upscale yet quaint experience, head to The 1770 House. Set in an 18th-century farmhouse, the prix-fixe menu highlights local seafood, meats and produce. Dishes may include Montauk pearl oysters, Long Island duck breast and artisanal cheeses. Their garden supplies many of the fresh herbs, fruits and vegetables. An impressive wine cellar rounds out the offerings.
– Location: East Hampton, NY
– Price range: $$$$
With amazing eats and drinks in a picturesque setting, the Hamptons is a locavore’s delight. Bon appetit!
Sharon Howe is a creative person with diverse talents. She writes engaging articles for WonderWorldSpace.com, where she works as a content writer. Writing allows Sharon to inform and captivate readers. Additionally, Sharon pursues music as a hobby, which allows her to showcase her artistic abilities in another creative area.